As reprinted from 09/29/2008
Financial meltdown: How it all happened
As Arizona state treasurer, my office manages a $12 billion portfolio and last year distributed profits of over $500 million to state and local governments. Last week, I watched in horror as the U.S. government’s schizophrenic actions created this financial meltdown. Now, they want nearly a trillion taxpayer dollars to fix it. Action is needed immediately, but taxpayers should not pay for others’ mistakes. The last thing we need is FEMA running our local bank. Our financial system is in a logjam, gripped by fear. The proposal to buy all the logs to remove the jam is expensive and rewards those who took large risks as much as those who did not. Instead, treat the disease directly, make the system more transparent and separate the good loans from the bad, saving taxpayers hard-earned cash. Main Street home buyers, Wall Street investors and the federal government are sitting on piles of debt. Easy money led to low lending standards, fueling housing speculation in Arizona and elsewhere. Because money was easy to get, lenders lowered standards to attract more borrowers. These debts were then bundled together and sold on Wall Street to institutional investors to raise capital to make more loans. The problem was a lack of transparency; bundling loans obscured the risks from investors. Prime loans were bundled together with jumbos, subprime loans and others while still receiving “A” ratings. Many investors just assumed the “A” rating meant all mortgages inside were safe. In August of last year, Wall Street realized that it owned subprime loans in portfolios that did not plan for that risk. At that point, the market froze. The housing bubble had burst and subprime loans were now seen as contaminated; anything they touched was considered toxic risk that no one wanted to buy. The lack of transparency in bundled mortgages made it difficult to know how many subprime loans were inside. Therefore, all mortgage securities were treated as toxic. Investors avoided all mortgages to prevent accidentally buying subprime. It’s like the adage: “One bad apple spoils the barrel.” So it was with subprime spoiling the entire mortgage market. New accounting rules designed for liquid markets now began to put the squeeze on banks even though more than 90 percent of Americans are still paying their mortgages. After the fraud at Enron, Congress changed the accounting rules to “mark to market.” Assets had to be priced according to what the market said they were worth if you liquidated them today. This was a very good rule for preventing unscrupulous individuals from overinflating their balance sheets. However, it works only when a functioning and liquid market exists to price the assets. When mortgage markets froze last August, demand evaporated for the now-toxic mortgage bundles. This crushed many banks’ balance sheets as they had to list mortgages at pennies on the dollar. Instead of having these assets on the books as collateral to make more loans, banks now needed to borrow money to stay afloat. Banks, however, stopped lending to other banks due to fear of getting indirect exposure to subprime loans. Banks depend on short-term cash to stay afloat. A total credit freeze puts our financial system in peril. Since the Great Depression, the Federal Reserve has been the lender of last resort to banks. During a crisis, if short-term cash ran dry, they could borrow from the Fed in order to prevent a run on the bank. When Bear Stearns faced a liquidity crisis, the Fed provided backstop lending to JPMorgan to assume Bear’s assets and liabilities. It promised the same assurances to other investment banks in this liquidity crisis. This contained the problem for a while. Confidence was shaken, but given the commitment to help banks get through any short-term liquidity crisis, the market was likely to avoid catastrophic failure. Then, the government caused the catastrophic failure it was trying to prevent. Despite nearly a year of promises, after the markets closed, the government reversed its position. It would not provide the same backstop as Bear Stearns to Lehman Brothers, an investment bank with positive net assets of $26 billion. It forced a company that was “A” rated on a Friday to file bankruptcy the following Sunday. Panic gripped the financial markets. The forced bankruptcy of Lehman destroyed insurance company AIG’s balance sheet. As fear ravaged investment portfolios, the government reversed itself again. It seized control of AIG, nationalizing it and pouring in $85 billion. By week’s end, the government had spent more money trying to contain the firestorm it unleashed by reneging on Lehman than it would have cost to support its sale. Worldwide, investors (and taxpayers) were losing confidence in U.S. government economic leaders. The government is supposed to be the referee, calling a fair game, not choosing winners and losers. The original strategy of providing only emergency lending during a liquidity crisis made sense. Nationalizing financial institutions does not. When your neighbor’s house is on fire, you lend him a hose; you don’t have him sign over the deed to the house before you help put out the fire. Congress needs to take action to fix this problem immediately; the longer it waits, the more damage is done. But it needs to treat the disease. Allow the mortgage bundles to be broken up, separate the toxic subprime loans that are causing the logjam from all other loans. Provide insurance for all other mortgages. This way, the 90 percent of Americans who are still paying their mortgages are rewarded for doing so, and the fear that has gripped the markets about the housing bubble will subside. Allow banks to value the now-insured loans based upon how many are still paying their mortgages, rather than liquidation value. This will unfreeze credit and get our economy moving again (and it’s a lot cheaper than just buying everything). I would rather bet on the majority of Americans who pay their mortgages, rather than bail out those who made risky investments. Dean Martin, a Republican, is Arizona’s Treasurer

In recent months, the nation’s two largest mortgage finance lenders have come under increasing scrutiny at the hands of Congress, the Justice Department and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The Federal National Mortgage Association, nicknamed Fannie Mae, and the Federal Home Mortgage Corporation, nicknamed Freddie Mac, have operated since 1968 as government sponsored enterprises (GSEs). This means that, although the two companies are privately owned and operated by shareholders, they are protected financially by the support of the Federal Government. These government protections include access to a line of credit through the U.S. Treasury, exemption from state and local income taxes and exemption from SEC oversight. A recent accounting scandal at Freddie Mac that resulted in the replacement of three of the company’s top executives has led to mounting concerns over the privileged status these GSEs enjoy in the marketplace.

Fannie Mae was created in 1938 as part of Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s New Deal. The collapse of the national housing market in the wake of the Great Depression discouraged private lenders from investing in home loans. Fannie Mae was established in order to provide local banks with federal money to finance home mortgages in an attempt to raise levels of home ownership and the availability of affordable housing.

Initially, Fannie Mae operated like a national savings and loan, allowing local banks to charge low interest rates on mortgages for the benefit of the home buyer. This lead to the development of what is now known as the secondary mortgage market. Within the secondary mortgage market, companies such as Fannie Mae are able to borrow money from foreign investors at low interest rates because of the financial support that they receive from the U.S. Government. It is this ability to borrow at low rates that allows Fannie Mae to provide fixed interest rate mortgages with low down payments to home buyers. Fannie Mae makes a profit from the difference between the interest rates homeowners pay and foreign lenders charge.

For the first thirty years following its inception, Fannie Mae held a veritable monopoly over the secondary mortgage market. In 1968, due to fiscal pressures created by the Vietnam War, Lyndon B. Johnson privatized Fannie Mae in order to remove it from the national budget. At this point, Fannie Mae began operating as a GSE, generating profits for stock holders while enjoying the benefits of exemption from taxation and oversight as well as implied government backing. In order to prevent any further monopolization of the market, a second GSE known as Freddie Mac was created in 1970. Currently, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac control about 90 percent of the nation’s secondary mortgage market.

GSEs such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mae, with their combination of private enterprise and public backing have experienced a period of unprecedented financial growth over the past few decades. The current assets of these two companies combine for a total that is 45 percent greater than that of the nation’s largest bank.

On the other hand, their combined debt is equal to 46 percent of the current national debt. It is this combination of rapid growth and over leveraging that has lead to the current concerns of Congress, the Justice Department and the SEC with regards to the financial practices of these GSEs.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the only two Fortune 500 companies that are not required to inform the public about any financial difficulties that they may be having. In the event that there was some sort of financial collapse within either of these companies, U.S. taxpayers could be held responsible for hundreds of billions of dollars in outstanding debts. A recent investigation by the Justice Department and the SEC into the accounting practices at Freddie Mac revealed accounting errors in the amount of 4.5 to 4.7 billion dollars and resulted in the termination of three of the company’s top executives. Ongoing investigations by Congress, particular the House Finance Services subcommittee that oversees the activity of GSEs, will determine the future role of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and the secondary mortgage market that they dominate.

What Are the Origins of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae?
By Rob Alford

Mr. Alford is a student at the University of Washington and an HNN intern.

This article has nothing at all to do with Arizona Real Estate at all.  I think it is one of the best emails I have received in years and wanted to share it.  I would love to know who wrote this letter, but it does not matter.  Too often we are caught up in our own lives to consider that which others are dealing with.  After reading this article I just wanted to say thank you to everyone who has served in our armed forces.  THANK YOU!!!!!!!!! 

 Below is the email originally sent by Alan Brumer, a past client. 

Luke AFB is west of Phoenix and is rapidly being surrounded by civilization that complains about the noise from the base and its planes, forgetting that it was there long before they were.

A certain lieutenant colonel at Luke AFB deserves a big pat on the back.

Apparently, an individual who lives somewhere near Luke AFB wrote the local paper complaining about a group of F-16s that disturbed his/her day at the mall. When that individual read the response from a Luke AFB officer, it must have stung quite a bit.

The complaint:

“Question of the day for Luke Air Force Base: Whom do we thank for the morning air show? Last Wednesday, at precisely 9:11 a.m., a tight formation of four F-16 jets made a low pass over Arrowhead Mall, continuing west over Bell Road at approximately 500 feet. Imagine our good fortune! Do the Tom Cruise-wannabes feel we need this wake-up call, or were they trying to impress the cashiers at Mervyns early bird special? Any response would be appreciated.”

The response:

Regarding “A wake-up call from Luke’s jets” (Letters, Thursday): On June 15, at precisely 9:12 a.m., a perfectly timed four-ship flyby of F-16s from the 63rd Fighter Squadron at Luke Air Force Base flew over the grave of Capt. Jeremy Fresques.  Capt. Fresques was an Air Force officer who was previously stationed at Luke Air Force Base and was killed in Iraq on May 30, Memorial Day.

At 9 a.m. on June 15, his family and friends gathered at Sunland Memorial Park in Sun City to mourn the loss of a husband, son and friend. Based on the letter writer’s recount of the flyby, and because of the jet noise, I’m sure you didn’t hear the 21-gun salute, the playing of taps, or my words to the widow and parents of Capt. Fresques as I gave them their son’s flag on behalf of the President of the United States and all those BR veterans and servicemen and women who understand the sacrifices they have endured.  A four-ship flyby is a display of respect the Air Force pays to those who give their lives in defense of freedom. We are professional aviators and take our jobs seriously, and on June 15 what the letter writer witnessed was four officers lining up to pay their ultimate respects.

The letter writer asks, “Whom do we thank for the morning air show?” The 56th Fighter Wing will make the call for you, and forward your thanks to the widow and parents of Capt. Fresques, and thank them for you, for it was in their honor that my pilots flew the most honorable formation of their lives.

Resourceful Investors Find a Way to Prosper

It wasn’t that long ago that many people around the
US
were able to make exciting short term profits investing in real estate. The stories abound celebrating conquests of buying a home for $200,000 holding it for 30 days only to have a line down the street waiting to buy the property for $275,000. Well, those days are gone now. They have been replaced by the quivering voices of mortgage brokers hoping to find a program for a hard to finance would-be home owner.

Is it all doom and gloom? Absolutely not! The awesome news is that down, to sideways markets have historically been the best time to buy real estate. Our economic history has proven it time and time again. Foreclosures are on the rise, the mortgage business is down and financial institutions are getting it from both ends. This is the perfect storm. But how does an investor prosper in this market?

Don’t do all of the work yourself!

There, the secret is out. The really successful investors who know how to cash in on today’s market have a team of highly successful superstars on their side helping them navigate these often times turbulent waters of our real estate market. We have heard people say this before, build your team. We aren’t talking about just finding “bodies”. We aren’t telling you to go out and find a mortgage broker, attorney, accountant, property manager, etc. and all of your troubles will go away. The key is to find the “superstars.” Superstars are the experts that know more than you do about their area of expertise. They have helped other investors make money before and are helping them do it now. This will truly set you apart from your sea of competition and take your investing to the next level.

Imagine having a realtor on your side that spends much of his time finding REO (foreclosed) properties and negotiating with banks. Wouldn’t that save you an untold amount of time? Finding the superstar REO agent will put you in the know and increase your deal flow immensely. That is the exciting part but what about your accountant? They are like opinions, everyone has them. But have you searched out to find one that works with primarily with real estate investors? Who spends his time researching every changing tax and legal landscape of real estate investing to make sure you are not only taking all of your deductions but also help you design your entity structures for long term profit?

The other key is the right Mortgage Broker.  Search for this person, or possibly more than one, to find the best “deal” on each transaction.  This is what we mean by filling the stables with the superstars. Of course it takes time and experience to develop this team.  Ant the time is well worth it!  Ant there is no better time than now.  Rates are still down, prices have fallen dramatically, and the deals are there. 

So do your homework to build your Superstar team, then continue that homework as you work with that team, then celebrate your own results! 

  - Jon Hegreness“I appreciate your referrals.”

We’ve had a lot of excitement on the mortgage industry over the last couple of weeks.  Interest rates have been thrown around like a yo-yo and we’re hearing a lot of chatter about possible loan limit increases as outlined in this “economic stimulus package” being passed by our government. I wanted to drop you a quick line and outline how this figures to affect our Scottsdale Arizona Market.  In short…not at all.
 
While many markets in California will see increased loan limits to about 729K we in the valley are projected to see no increase.  This is because the formula they will use to determine loan amounts is now 417K or 125% of the County Median sales price, whichever is greater.  Unfortunately for those of us who work in Scottsdale and high end areas of Phoenix our County Median sales price is too low to push us over 417K.  The best I can offer is Flagstaff is projected to increase to about 450K.  If any of you should have questions concerning these regulations please feel free contact me at any time.  I am well connected with some incredible mortgage lenders that can help with new mortgages and refinances.  

  - Jon Hegreness

“I appreciate your referrals.”

The total number of homes on the market dipped down nearly 5% over the Holidays but have moved back up since. They are still sitting at a lower level, 45414 or down about 2%, from the end of the year. However the current rate of closings is very low due to the fact that it is reflecting activity from the end of the year. Closes in the previous month were 2362 which gives us a supply of 19 1/4 months.

I also keep track of but don’t usually report current Pending sales. The good news is these are at the highest level that I have seen since last August PM (Pre-Meltdown). We’ll see if this translates in to more closings in the next month.

Best market in the Valley continues to be the SE area at 15 3/4 months supply and next is
Scottsdale under $1M at 17 1/4 months.

Luxury Markets are at a staggering 3 1/2 YEAR supply level.

The comparison of current active listing change is based on the previous week’s inventory. Supply numbers are based on the number of closings in the previous month, divided in to the total number of active listings. This data is for Single Family Detached homes only and does not include patio homes, condos, or town homes.

Entire MLS (Maricopa and Northern Pinal county), listing inventories are unchanged from last week. Total of 45414 active listings. Based on current rate of closings, about a 19 1/4 month supply.

200’s area (
Central Phoenix). Listing inventories are unchanged from last week. Total of 6396 active listings. About a 21 month supply.

300’s area (

West
Valley). Listing inventories are unchanged from last week. Total of 15111 active listings. About a 20 month supply.

400’s area (NE Valley), Listing inventories are up 1% from last week. Total of 7589 active listings. About a 21 1/2 month supply.

500 #700’s area (SE Valley), Listing inventories are unchanged from last week. Total of 11341 active listings. About a 15 3/4 month supply.

Scottsdale over $1m. Listings inventories are up 2% from last week.
Total of 1601 active listings. About a 40 month supply.

Scottsdale under $1m. Listing inventories are unchanged from last week. Total of 2555 active listings. About a 17 1/4 month supply.

Paradise
Valley. Listing inventories are up 6% from last week. Total of 420 active listings. About a 42 month supply.

  - Jon Hegreness“I appreciate your referrals.”

19 Years of National Market Shifts

  • What goes up must come down
  • What comes down will not stay there

  This is part 1 in a 10 part series.  Please check back each week.

When you say “Big Game” in Arizona you can’t help but think of the football game in Glendale, even if you’re not a football fan.  Arizona also hosts other big games like the FBR Open and the Barrett/Jackson car auction; there is literally something for everyone.  Even those who aren’t sports fans can’t help but appreciate the fabulous weather, stunning scenery and warm hospitality.  But, the REAL “Big Game” in Arizona is real estate.  I hope that the “white noise” of a negative national press in the financial sector doesn’t obscure the positive aspects of what is happening in Arizona.  Local real estate gurus in their 2008 forecasts give us high marks in comparison with the rest of the country predicting a population growth of +2.7%, employment at +2%, personal income +5.5% and retail sales at +1.5%.   This is when the knowledgeable players get in the game, to take advantage of interest rates at historic lows and the abundance of housing choices.  Even the rise in foreclosures gives real estate a boost whether you are a buyer occupant or an investor.  When you consider the fact that according to the National Association of REALTORS®, the value of homes nearly doubles every ten years, this would be the perfect time to get off the bench and start playing.

With all the bad news from the economic sector of our economy, you may have missed some of this; Forbes magazine ranks us 3rd in its “Best US Cities for Jobs” list, Business 2.0 magazine rates us a top destination city for relocations and one of America’s hottest job markets.   And, CNN ranked the Phoenix/Tucson area as one of the top 10 “megapolitans” in the U.S.

You have to ask yourself, how bad is the economy when a 30 second commercial during the Super Bowl costs approximately $2.3 million?  Don’t wait to buy real estate, buy real estate and wait.  Whether you are a Patriots or Giants fan, its time to get off the sidelines and get into the REAL game in Arizona - real estate.

(I recently received this in an email and thought I would share it.) 

Bill Gates recently gave a speech at a High School about 11 things they did not and will not learn in school. He talks about how feel-good, politically correct teachings created a generation of kids with no concept of reality and how this concept set them up for failure in the real world.
 

Rule 1 : Life is not fair - get used to it!
Rule 2 : The world won’t care about your self-esteem. The world will expect you to accomplish something BEFORE you feel good about yourself.
 

Rule 3 : You will NOT make $60,000 a year right out of high school. You won’t be a vice-president with a car phone until you earn both.
 

Rule 4 : If you think your teacher is tough, wait till you get a boss.
 

Rule 5 : Flipping burgers is not beneath your dignity. Your Grandparents had a different word for burger flipping: they called it opportunity.
Rule 6 : If you mess up, it’s not your parents’ fault, so don’t whine about your mistakes, learn from them.
Rule 7 : Before you were born, your parents weren’t as boring as they are now. They got that way from paying your bills, cleaning your clothes and listening to you talk about how cool you thought you were. So before you save the rain forest from the parasites of your parent’s generation, try delousing the closet in your own room.
Rule 8 : Your school may have done away with winners and losers, but life HAS NOT. In some schools, they have abolished failing grades and they’ll give you as MANY TIMES as you want to get the right answer. This doesn’t bear the slightest resemblance to ANYTHING in real life.
Rule 9 : Life is not divided into semesters. You don’t get summers off and very few employers are interested in helping you FIND YOURSELF. Do that on your own time.
 

Rule 10 : Television is NOT real life. In real life people actually have to leave the coffee shop and go to jobs.
 

Rule 11 : Be nice to nerds. Chances are you’ll end up working for one.

Four times a year the National Association of Realtors releases a report on our Phoenix, AZ market.  Below is a link to this report.  In my opinion this is the best source of Real Estate information available in one report.

http://www.armls.com/pdfs/ARMLS%203q2007.pdf

1 | 2 | 3 | 4